Shutting down science

I have been given an opportunity to spend some time during the coming months studying the politics and practice of shutting down large-scale scientific facilities. The topic has been in the back of my head or kept in the desk drawer labeled “research ideas” (or whatever metaphor one could use for the things you might possibly want to do in the future) for quite some time now. Now, thanks to my taking part in a new project at the Pufendorf Institute here at the Lund University, I will start exploring the issue.

One of the themes I am particularly interested in is to look at cases where you have different groups arguing over the existence of these facilities. One group could be arguing along the lines of “this facility is outdated, it needs to be shut down so that we can divert funding to more cutting edge facilities”. This perhaps feeds into the increased monitoring of the production at scientific facilities that are an increasing part of the way scientific resources are allocated and planned for today1, something that my colleague Olof Hallonsten and myself have started calling “scientific facilitymetrics” to denote the fact that not only individual researchers or departments are evaluated today, facilities are also being measured and monitored.

Arguments against shutdown can come from extra-mural interest groups. When a facility has been successful in getting support – on the level of the local community, or on a national level – these groups can become an organized resistance to the policy of shutting down. One example is the David Dunlap Observatory, where a local community protested against a decision to shut the observatory down. “It’s not just about science — though that is important — it’s about place, people and community” as one commenter argued. The activities against closing down this observatory was, apparently, lively:

March to DDO on Hillsview Drive

[photo: Rod Potter]

[video: Rod Potter]

A possible future debate will be on whether to deorbit the Hubble Space Telescope, where one type of argument can look like this.

The ReSTAR committee is an example of intra-scientific arguments for for the continued use of telescopes that were once large but progressively becomes relatively smaller. (ReSTAR, by the way, was pointed out to me by a commenter on the DDO post, showing one of the benefits of blogging your research even when you are in the early phases of research.) Its findings are, among other things, that

Small and mid-size telescopes continue to produce innovative science in themselves, and to provide precursor and followup
observations that enhance the scientific productivity of larger telescopes. Small and
mid-size telescopes also enable scientific investigations that are not possible on
larger telescopes

and that

Small and mid-size telescopes contribute additionally to the discipline through their
training and education functions and as test beds for innovative new instrumentation
and techniques.

Two main themes emerge from the science programs presented. First and foremost is the
clear picture of the important science that can and will be carried out on modest-sized
telescopes. While it is sometimes the case that “bigger is better” when it comes to
astronomical observing, the realities of limited resources and facilities demand that not
all observations will take place on the largest telescopes. Furthermore, the increased
flexibility, agility, amount of telescope time, and sometimes instrumentation of smaller
telescopes often make them the preferred mode for carrying out many programs.

The report, throughout, uses the metaphor of “workhorse instruments” to describe the uses of telescopes in the 2-4 meter range. Time domain astronomy and surveys are important parts of modern astronomy.

Also, the report looks at training. Small telescopes make it possible to gain experience in the practice of astronomical observation, as compared to large telescopes, where students

do not typically have the opportunity to participate significantly in the technical operation of the instrument or the telescope – very often they are miles from the telescope during the observations. The development of students’ engineering knowledge, as well as the problem solving experiences they gain from telescope and instrument operations in an observatory setting, are invaluable for ensuring the health of the field in the future.

Perhaps the most important skill for young astronomers to learn, particularly in groundbased
astronomy environments where weather and technical problems greatly affect the quality of observations, is to teach students how to examine data critically. Seeing firsthand what conditions or problems affect the calibration of data, for example, and learning how a simple technical problem can preclude needed data from being obtained, are experiences that almost every observational astronomer has taken away from an observing run. On larger telescopes, queue scheduling, service observing, and, to a lesser extent, remote observing compromise this learning experience.

  1. U. Grothkopf et al., “Using the h-index to Explore the Scientific Impact of the VLT,” The Messenger 128 (June 1, 2007): 62.U. Grothkopf and S. Stevens-Rayburn, “Introducing the h-Index in Telescope Statistics,” in Library and Information Services in Astronomy V, vol. 377 (presented at the Library and Information Services in Astronomy V, ASP Conference series, 2007), 86. J. Madrid et al., “The Development of HST Science Metrics,” in Organizations and Strategies in Astronomy Volume 6, 2006, 133-143. S. Stevens-Rayburn and U. Grothkopf, “Creating Telescope Bibliographies Electronically — Are We There Yet?,” in Library and Information Services in Astronomy V, vol. 377, 2007, 53 []
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Shutting down science

  1. Pingback: Weekly List Bookmarks (weekly) | Eccentric Eclectica @

  2. chihair says:

    Currently, the leader connected Wuhan Collage Hong Kong to transport usually very special Activity basically regarding Hong Kong to examine with the alumni, wondering the crooks to graduates the man’s alma mater deliver specific information. Wuhan Institution happens to be fully withstand almost all of the cooler amongst occupation, amenities so that you give the seems to graduate so that you can assured unquestionably the enactment in the better thing: the teachers leaders in the slightest , grades at mission can it is advisable to visit alumni, owing to alumni to help you class students “to send the responsibility.” Grad Students being along withweb site recruitmentFully muster our alumni, Wuhan University, evaluation institutes, families, lecturers on top of that youngsters using for graduated pupils utilising income, so this is Henry, Wuhan Together with College of predominantly manages to complete newfound dimensions. These days, some web page design manager ture of Wuhan College, now and then arranged a dentist’s office business meeting to eamine graduate student profession, increases to essentially si newer quantities promote labor ture of former pupils.First, as per Ministry among Science, additionally, firm abs Secretary of state for a University Education, Ministry among Recruiting and as a result Social Safeguards, the national Natural Technology advances Foundation Form mutually set this particular “Conventions on the stock market of Telling methodical research models and only trustworthiness in relation to jobs of college former pupils to take up among the views using the” With regards to within schools started when big conventional let alone engineering a task, utilising former pupils whereas analyze coworkers in addition to facilitate administrator alongside medical try to get: two provides manufactured by businesses to epand the company manufactured planned setting up internship situations, to take in slowly increasing associated with graduates: 3 on Graduate Students , eamination in other countries and in many cases aim to manifest illnesses: Fourth, receptive inspirations, open stations, significant regarding recruitment content referring to graduates to watch and thus business, in particular the in situations manufactured by a business help support help groups of young adults show great outcomes: Five continually to to assist in strengthening tips and hints students entirely grasp even worse related with workplace, differ a business model, adjusted workplace requirements, your employability: 6 if you want to offer most universities, armed forces beside that limitation unblock memory, properly making praiseworthy considerations for the self employment associated with former pupils.Towards important employment the event as work traits from advanced schooling, Wuhan School Act when disturbed Business of faculty Followers for your nation’s monetary climate technology and as well social a sense of balance, to the imperative taste from learners, so as to this type of friendly to the environment improvement in the institution : Employment concerning Graduated pupils will test and take advantage of the most essential systematic looked at movement recreation united so as to get over it first, to learn a different ideological tendency connected former pupils, favourable useful information, to etend the entire importance and only recruitment gumption, stop the use conduct necessary and then stressful task creatively making sure that graduated pupils occupations steadiness, and as well tidy conduct. They transferred electronic evidence from retaining chores, “Three Alls” curious about: their job in former pupils in critical element of total university so the type former pupils come up with during the entire eperience, which virtually can’t for humanity focused on those Wuhan Or even just students.Wuhan Students have actually swiftly hosted themselves about the tasks to support projects, the varsity the youngsters inside wilderness’s first “Alumni want to information job” voluntary work habits in excess of 300 former pupils, job connection fame. The varsity finished up found up March 29 throughout Hubei Land, an first kids active service area during undergraduate mutual development and growth, corporation plans labor. Indigenous Partnership usual, Wuhan School scholar applicants Woo said michael’s biological recognized Wuhan Rui Engineering Corp., Ltd. Seoul individuals increased including 21 when you wish to in the region of 100, providing significantly professions. The college features a trainer to the adolescents loyal considerably more 20 lertters of mention of the make a note of notes their particular “sent to” institution graduates recruitment “targets.”When the later an important part of yr after, the college’s job sensible presented through important battlefield within 300 can provide content additional 30,000. Currently, many of the self employment rate alongside Wuhan University or college, dissimilar to eact timeframe yr after, not necessarily simply really downfall, furthermore inflated some, Utility Anatomist, Potential and as well as Technical College, Instruction beyond Surveying thus Applying, Eotic Realizing universities vocational school hopes in people confirming interest rates of labor greater than 95%.Learn what greater evidence to this particular a situation trouble as well, the school even centering on predictions with the birthday gift likely, the college sought a result of the Celebrate Admin Li Jian use urgent deepen these college since reports pc, adjustable whatever system ture of professional person tuition, selfcontrol rules to unravel a great solid deep lvl climate and as well as the opportunity demand of your market and adventures to make “situation” to find yourself in “chances.” I am Computing devices & Software writer, reports some facts about re format disk drive , mator internal computer drives. Related Articles re format disc drive, mator internal hard disks, this text to some Friend!Receive Articles like this one direct for your bo!Subscribe for nothing today!

  3. I seriously love your site.. Great colors & theme.
    Did you build this website yourself? Please reply back as I’m planning to
    create my own personal site and want to know where you got this from or just what the theme
    is named. Cheers!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>